GOOGLE OR CHATGPT?...........

You've heard the advice.

"Optimize for AI search."

"Show up in ChatGPT."

"Get recommended by Claude."

Great. But here's the problem:

You don't have unlimited time or budget.

You can't be everywhere at once. You can't master every platform. You can't optimize for everything.

So the question becomes: Where do you actually invest your effort?

Google AI Overviews? ChatGPT? Both?

And if you pick wrong, you waste months spinning your wheels while competitors dominate the platform that actually matters.

Let me cut through the noise and show you exactly where lawyers should focus in 2025.

Here's what I hear constantly:

"Should I optimize for Google or ChatGPT?"

"Which platform gets more legal searches?"

"Do I need to pick one or do both?"

"Where are my potential clients actually searching?"

Fair questions. And the answer matters because your time is limited.

You're running a practice. Meeting with clients. Handling cases. Doing the actual legal work that pays the bills.

You don't have 40 hours a week to become a marketing expert.

So you need to know: Where does effort matter most?

Let me break it down.

First, let's talk about what Google AI Overviews actually are.

You've seen them. When you Google a question, sometimes you get this AI-generated summary box at the top.

Not the traditional "10 blue links." An actual answer synthesized by AI.

Example: Someone searches "Do I need a lawyer for a DUI in Washington?"

Google AI Overview shows a summary. Maybe 3-4 paragraphs. Sources listed below.

This is Google's answer to ChatGPT.

They're not showing you options anymore. They're giving you the answer — and citing sources.

What This Means for Lawyers:

Google AI Overviews pull from:

• Your website content

• Your Google Business Profile

• High-authority legal directories

• Schema-marked structured data

• Content that's already ranking well

Translation: If you're doing good SEO, you have a shot at Google AI Overviews.

But there's a catch.

The Google AI Overview Problem:

Google still shows multiple sources. The AI synthesizes from several sites.

So even if your content is cited, you're sharing the spotlight with 2-4 other law firms.

You're not THE answer. You're ONE OF the answers.

That's different from ChatGPT.

ChatGPT works completely differently.

When someone asks "Who's a good DUI attorney in Seattle?" — ChatGPT doesn't show 10 options.

It recommends one. Maybe two.

"I'd suggest reaching out to Sarah Martinez at Martinez Law. She specializes in DUI defense and has excellent client reviews."

Done. No comparison shopping. No scrolling through options.

ChatGPT is making the decision FOR the searcher.

What This Means for Lawyers:

ChatGPT recommendations are based on:

• Consistent online presence across platforms

• Schema markup (critical for AI understanding)

• Review volume and recency

• Content depth demonstrating expertise

• Video presence showing authenticity

• Third-party validation (mentions on other sites)

Translation: ChatGPT rewards authority signals more than keyword optimization.

The ChatGPT Advantage:

When ChatGPT recommends you, you're not competing with 5 other firms.

You ARE the recommendation.

That's massive. Because people trust AI recommendations like they trust friend referrals.

"ChatGPT said to call you" is the new "My friend said you're great."

Let's talk numbers.

Google Search Volume:

• 8.5 billion searches per day globally

• ~90% of all search traffic

• Mature user base (everyone uses Google)

• Local intent searches dominate for lawyers

ChatGPT Usage:

• 100+ million weekly active users (as of late 2024)

• Growing 20%+ month over month

• Younger, tech-savvy demographic

• Question-based, advice-seeking queries

Here's the truth: Google still gets way more traffic.

But ChatGPT users have different intent.

Google Users:

• "DUI lawyer Seattle" (searching for options)

• "Best family law attorney near me" (comparison shopping)

• "Estate planning lawyer cost" (researching)

They're in research mode. Comparing. Evaluating. Price shopping.

ChatGPT Users:

• "I got a DUI. What should I do?" (seeking guidance)

• "Who's a good divorce attorney to work with?" (asking for recommendation)

• "Help me understand estate planning" (learning first, hiring second)

They're in advice mode. They want help NOW. They trust AI to guide them.

Different platforms. Different intent. Different results.

Here's what matters more than volume: Quality of leads.

Google AI Overview Leads:

• Often price shopping

• Comparing multiple firms

• May not call for days/weeks

• Lower trust (still researching)

• Higher competition (saw 3-5 firms)

Conversion rate: 1-3% typically

ChatGPT Recommendation Leads:

• Pre-sold on you specifically

• AI vouched for you (social proof)

• Often call same day

• Higher trust (AI recommended)

• No comparison (you're THE choice)

Conversion rate: 10-25% typically

Yes, you read that right.

ChatGPT leads convert 5-10X better because they're not shopping. They're seeking the person AI told them to hire.

Let me make this crystal clear.

GOOGLE AI OVERVIEWS

Strengths: ✅ Massive traffic volume (billions of searches) ✅ High local intent ("lawyer near me") ✅ Builds on existing SEO work ✅ Familiar to all demographics ✅ Captures ready-to-hire searchers

Weaknesses: ❌ Shared recommendations (you're one of several) ❌ Price-shopping mentality ❌ Requires strong existing SEO ❌ Competitive (everyone optimizes for Google) ❌ Lower conversion rates

Best for:

• Established firms with good SEO

• High-volume practice areas

• Competitive markets where visibility matters

• Attorneys who need consistent lead flow
  

Strengths: ✅ Exclusive recommendations (you're THE choice) ✅ Pre-sold leads (AI vouched for you) ✅ Higher conversion rates (5-10X) ✅ Less competition (most lawyers aren't optimizing) ✅ Growing user base (20%+ monthly)

Weaknesses: ❌ Lower total volume (vs Google) ❌ Requires strong authority signals ❌ Newer user behavior (still evolving) ❌ Skews younger demographic ❌ Less predictable (recommendations vary)

Best for:

• Boutique firms seeking quality over quantity

• Attorneys building authority-based practices

• Early adopters willing to test new platforms

• Firms tired of price-shopping leads

Here's what most marketing agencies won't tell you:

You can't win at both immediately.

Not with limited time. Not with limited budget.

The optimization strategies overlap, but they're not identical.

Google AI Overviews prioritize:

• Traditional SEO signals

• Keyword optimization

• Website speed and technical SEO

• Local citations and NAP consistency

• Google Business Profile optimization

ChatGPT prioritizes:

• Authority signals and trust

• Consistent content creation

• Schema markup (even more critical)

• Review recency and volume

• Video content and authenticity

You can do SOME things that help both. (Schema, reviews, content)

But if you're trying to master both platforms from scratch, you'll spread yourself too thin and dominate neither.

Pick your battlefield.

Let me give you the framework.

Choose GOOGLE AI OVERVIEWS if:

✅ You already have decent SEO (ranking page 1-2) ✅ You practice in high-volume areas (personal injury, family law, DUI) ✅ You're in a competitive metro market (lots of searches) ✅ You need predictable lead volume NOW ✅ You have budget for ongoing SEO work

Action Plan:

1. Optimize existing high-ranking content

2. Add structured data (schema markup)

3. Improve Google Business Profile

4. Build local citations

5. Target featured snippet opportunities

Timeline: 60-90 days to see movement

Choose CHATGPT if:

✅ Your SEO is weak or nonexistent ✅ You're tired of low-quality, price-shopping leads ✅ You want to build long-term authority ✅ You're comfortable with smaller volume, higher quality ✅ You're an early adopter willing to test new approaches

Action Plan:

1. Build consistent content presence (video + written)

2. Implement comprehensive schema markup for attorneys (or whatever your business model)

3. Collect recent reviews systematically

4. Create authority content (answer real questions)

5. Show up authentically (video is critical)

Timeline: 60-90 days to start appearing

Do BOTH if:

✅ You have dedicated marketing resources (team or agency) ✅ You have 10+ hours/week for content creation ✅ Your SEO is already strong ✅ You're committed to long-term authority building ✅ You can invest 6+ months without immediate ROI pressure

Action Plan:

1. Maintain Google SEO fundamentals

2. Add AI-specific optimizations (schema, content depth)

3. Build consistent authority content for ChatGPT

4. Leverage content across both platforms

5. Track which platform drives better ROI

Timeline: 90-180 days for full optimization

If you're reading this and thinking "I just want to know what to DO" - here's my advice:

Start with Google AI Overviews IF:

• You already rank for some keywords

• You need leads this month/quarter

• You understand SEO basics

Start with ChatGPT IF:

• Your SEO is broken or nonexistent

• You want better quality over quantity

• You're building from scratch anyway

BUT HERE'S THE SECRET:

There's massive overlap in what BOTH platforms need:

1. Schema markup (critical for both)

2. Helpful content (answering real questions)

3. Recent reviews (trust signals)

4. Consistent presence (ongoing activity)

5. Clear expertise (specialty focus)

Do these five things, and you'll improve in BOTH.

So stop overthinking the platform choice.

Start building the foundation that works everywhere.

Here's what nobody talks about:

The platform doesn't matter if your fundamentals suck.

I've seen attorneys obsess over "Google vs ChatGPT" while their:

• Website loads in 8 seconds

• Schema markup is nonexistent

• Last Google review is from 2021

• Content library is one blog post from 2019

• Social media is dead for 6 months

Fix the foundation first.

Then worry about platform strategy.

Because here's the truth: Strong fundamentals win on every platform.

• Schema markup helps Google AND ChatGPT

• Recent reviews matter to Google AND ChatGPT

• Quality content ranks on Google AND ChatGPT

• Authority signals work on Google AND ChatGPT

Stop optimizing for platforms. Start optimizing for trust.

Want to know what the smartest attorneys are doing?

They're not choosing.

They're building assets that work everywhere:

Asset #1: Content Library

50+ articles answering every client question.

Works for:

• Google AI Overviews (pulls from your content)

• ChatGPT (recognizes your expertise)

• Direct search (people find your articles)

• Email marketing (nurture leads)

Asset #2: Video Presence

100+ short educational videos.

Works for:

• ChatGPT (authenticity signal)

• YouTube search (second largest search engine)

• Social media (LinkedIn, Instagram)

• Website conversion (builds trust)

Asset #3: Review Engine

Systematic collection of 5-star reviews.

Works for:

• Google rankings and AI Overviews

• ChatGPT recommendations

• Website conversion (social proof)

• Reputation management

Asset #4: Schema Markup

Complete structured data implementation.

Works for:

• Google understanding

• ChatGPT understanding

• Voice search

• Future AI platforms

Build these four assets, and you win on every platform that matters.

Now and in the future.

Here's my prediction:

In 12-24 months, this won't be "Google vs ChatGPT."

It'll be:

• Google AI Overviews

• ChatGPT

• Claude

• Perplexity

• Microsoft Copilot

• Whatever comes next

New AI platforms will keep launching.

If you optimize specifically for one platform, you'll have to re-optimize every time a new platform emerges.

But if you build real authority assets?

They work everywhere. Forever.

That's the difference between tactics and strategy.

Tactics: "Hack Google AI Overviews with these 7 tricks"

Strategy: "Build undeniable authority that AI can't ignore"

One works for 6 months. The other works for 6 years.

Choose wisely.

Still not sure where to focus? Ask yourself these questions:

Question 1: Do I need leads THIS quarter or can I build for next year?

• Need leads now → Google AI Overviews

• Building for future → ChatGPT

Question 2: Is my current SEO strong or weak?

• Strong SEO → Build on it with Google AI optimization

• Weak SEO → Start fresh with ChatGPT authority

Question 3: Do I want volume or quality?

• Volume → Google AI Overviews

• Quality → ChatGPT

Question 4: Am I building a volume practice or boutique practice?

• Volume practice → Google AI Overviews

• Boutique practice → ChatGPT

Question 5: Do I have time/resources for both?

• Yes → Do both

• No → Pick one based on answers above

Be honest with yourself.

Don't try to do everything. Do one thing well.

Alright. Here's your 90-day plan based on where you are:

SCENARIO A: Strong SEO, Need Volume Now

Focus: Google AI Overviews

Month 1:

• Add schema markup to all pages

• Optimize top 10 ranking articles for featured snippets

• Update Google Business Profile completely

• Target "People Also Ask" questions with content

Month 2:

• Create 10 new articles targeting AI Overview opportunities

• Build local citations

• Collect 10+ new Google reviews

• Improve page speed

Month 3:

• Monitor Google Search Console for AI Overview appearances

• Double down on what's working

• Create more content in successful topics

SCENARIO B: Weak SEO, Want Quality Leads

Focus: ChatGPT

Month 1:

• Implement complete schema markup

• Create 15-20 short educational videos

• Write 10 articles answering real client questions

• Set up review collection system

Month 2:

• Post 3-4X per week on LinkedIn

• Upload all videos to YouTube

• Publish 2-3 blog posts weekly

• Get 15+ new reviews

Month 3:

• Test ChatGPT to see if you appear

• Continue consistent content production

• Build video library to 50+ videos

• Establish authority presence

SCENARIO C: Have Resources, Want Both

Focus: Dual Optimization

Month 1:

• Schema markup (helps both)

• Content creation system (publish 3X/week)

• Review collection (helps both)

• Google Business Profile optimization

Month 2:

• Google: Featured snippet targeting

• ChatGPT: Video content creation

• Both: Answer common client questions

• Both: Build review momentum

Month 3:

• Measure which platform drives better ROI

• Allocate more resources to winner

• Maintain baseline effort on both

• Optimize based on data

Look, the platform debate is a distraction.

Google vs ChatGPT. Traditional vs AI. Old school vs new school.

None of it matters if you're not building real authority.

The attorneys winning right now — on Google AND ChatGPT — aren't the ones with the cleverest hacks.

They're the ones who:

• Show up consistently

• Answer real questions

• Build genuine expertise

• Earn real trust

• Create real value

Do that, and every platform works.

Don't do that, and no platform saves you.

Ready to dominate both Google AI Overviews and ChatGPT?

📞 Schedule a free 15-minute Authority Audit and we'll show you exactly where you should focus first based on YOUR specific situation — not generic advice.

Because the right platform for your competitor might be the wrong platform for you.

Let's find YOUR winning strategy. Contact me today!

This is a paragraph